The Circular Home · Research assignment 02 · Preliminary
Would Durra Panel partitions beat timber and plasterboard?
A complete-assembly comparison for the Mallee reference home, not a panel price comparison. Every input is labelled as a published figure, a manufacturer claim or our own assumption, and no supplier has quoted.
The short version
For the 56 m² of internal partitions we judge eligible for Durra Panel (wall by wall in section 1; wet, garage, service-heavy and possibly structural walls stay conventional), our central estimate is $8,100 for a timber stud and plasterboard wall and $9,900 for a Durra Panel wall, ex GST, installed and painted. On these assumptions Durra is dearer by about 22% per m², or about $1,800, with a range of +$1,000 to +$3,100 across our low and high inputs. On the whole house that is 0.5% of the baseline central contract price, a small effect on the whole house. The gap per m² is wider than the 18% in our first version because the fixed handling hours and the services and door allowances now fall on a smaller eligible area.
The panel price is the biggest single driver. At the reported $39.10 per m² it is more than the plasterboard, timber and batts it replaces, and the wall still needs freight, channels, joint treatment and an extra sealer coat on its paper face. The break-even panel price in our central case is about $11 per m², against the reported $39.10 (low case $19.45, high case $0.61). A written quote below that, delivered to Brisbane, would change the answer.
Labour. Our model shows a net saving of only about 2 labour hours on the eligible walls (low case 8, high case -1). The manufacturer’s one-wall comparison scales to about 20 hours. Our figure is smaller because we count framing and fixing, but also finish preparation, services chasing and extra painting. On the programme, Durra is about 2.5 working days longer (+0.5 weeks) in the central case, range +0.0 to +5.4 days. We do not accept that the manufacturer’s hour saving becomes a programme saving, because partition rough-in has to wait for the panels and painting takes longer.
Other qualifications. The panel weighs 18.5 kg per m² (S50), so the central order is about 1.2 tonnes before packaging, and handling and freight are kept as sensitivities pending a quotation. Finish is tested as three scenarios, services are counted by outlet and switch, and panels go in only after the building is weathertight. A single Durra panel has not been shown to match the acoustic performance of the insulated conventional partition. The 8.5-star window sensitivity is on the baseline page and is kept out of this comparison. Thinner partitions could add about 1.2 m² of floor (see section 5).
Ceilings. We have not costed a Durra ceiling. The manufacturer’s ceiling system is a steel grid with clamped panels designed for larger buildings, the Mallee ceiling needs R4.0 insulation the panel does not provide, and we found no span data. See section 6.
How far to trust this. Quantities are measured from the Mallee plans, but which walls are eligible is our reading of the floor plan. Almost every rate and hour is our assumption, because we found no published installed rate or labour hours we could rely on. The Durra price, the 16 against 6 hours and the one hour fire statement are manufacturer claims. The page is preliminary and built to be corrected.
1. What we compared, and the quantities
A. Conventional: Timber stud partition, 10 mm plasterboard both faces, R1.0 batts, set and painted. Source: Mallee Design Options pp 6 to 7: 10 mm plasterboard on timber framing with R1.0 batts (8.5 star option).
B. Durra Panel: Durra Panel S50 self-supporting partition, painted, no plasterboard or batts. Source: Ortech technical manual 6.1 to 6.4 (single panel wall, maximum 2.7 m self-supporting, top channel, timber floor plate, biscuit joints) and Durra product pages. The panel is self-supporting to 2.7 m according to the manufacturer’s manual, so it replaces the studs, both plasterboard layers and the batts. We still add a head channel, a timber floor plate, biscuit joints, and door reinforcement.
Equivalence. Both walls must be a painted partition at the Mallee ceiling height with doors and services. They are not equivalent on acoustic, fire and wet-area performance, so we limit the comparison to dry walls and treat the performance differences in section 5.
| Quantity | Value | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Partition length | 53.2 m (range 47.9 to 58.5) | Measured from the Mallee plans (our takeoff, range is scaling uncertainty) |
| Ceiling height | 2.7 m | Design Options p6: 2.7 m ceiling height |
| Wall area, one core | 143.6 m² | 53.2 m x 2.7 m (our takeoff) |
| Lined face area, both faces | 287.2 m² | Two faces of every wall |
| Eligible wall area by case, low / central / high | 20.0 / 56.2 / 82.8 m² | Wall by wall, see the table below |
| Eligible Durra wall area used for cost (central) | 56.2 m² | Excludes wet, garage, service-heavy and possibly structural walls |
| Internal doors | 8 (range 7 to 10), about 4 on eligible walls | Our reading of the floor plan (drawing 2): bedrooms 1 to 3 and the walk-in robe, all on the eligible corridor walls |
| Ceiling | 148 m², of which 48.6 m² raked | Measured; discussed separately below |
Eligible partitions, wall by wall
Read by us from the floor plan (drawing 2 of the technical drawings) against the groups in our takeoff. The plan carries no wall-type or structural notes, so structural status, wet faces and loads are our reading and must be confirmed with the designer and engineer. Lengths are the takeoff groups: 4.16 m x 2, 9.3 m, 17.1 m and five dividers of 3.70 m (53.2 m in all).
| Wall | Length | Area | Status | Low / central / high | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bedroom 3 | bedroom 2 divider | 3.70 m | 10.0 m² | Eligible | Y Y Y | Dry both sides. Robe and bedhead loads need fixing detail. |
| Walk-in robe | bedroom 1 divider | 3.70 m | 10.0 m² | Eligible | Y Y Y | Dry both sides. Shelving loads in the robe need fixing detail. |
| Corridor south wall, bedrooms 3, 2, robe and bedroom 1 (dry part) | 13.40 m | 36.2 m² | Eligible if not load-bearing | n Y Y | Long wall that may carry truss or roof loads. Panel is shown self-supporting for partitions only. Excluded in the low case until an engineer confirms. |
| Corridor south wall, bathroom and ensuite | 3.70 m | 10.0 m² | Excluded: wet area | n n n | Showers and tiling on the bathroom face. |
| Bedroom 2 | bathroom, bathroom | ensuite, ensuite | robe (3 walls) | 11.10 m | 30.0 m² | Excluded: wet area | n n n | Wet face on at least one side. |
| Laundry | study divider | 4.16 m | 11.2 m² | Excluded: wet area | n n n | Laundry, plumbing and wet face. |
| Study | kitchen divider | 4.16 m | 11.2 m² | Excluded: service-heavy | n n Y | Kitchen joinery, appliances and plumbing on one face. Included only in the high case. |
| Corridor north wall, study and kitchen part | 5.70 m | 15.4 m² | Excluded: service-heavy, possibly structural | n n Y | Joinery and services on the kitchen side, possibly load-bearing. Included only in the high case. |
| Corridor north wall, laundry part | 3.60 m | 9.7 m² | Excluded: wet area | n n n | Laundry face (our estimate of the laundry share of the 9.3 m). |
| Eligible, by case (low / central / high) | 7.4 m / 20.8 m / 30.7 m | 20.0 m² / 56.2 m² / 82.8 m² |
The walls between the garage and the house (about 4.2 m to the laundry and study, and the garage wall onto the entry corridor, from the plan) are not in the 53.2 m. They may need a fire separation and stay conventional. Confirm that they are counted as external or garage walls elsewhere in our takeoff. Ex GST, 2026 dollars, no escalation. Installed cost of the partition assembly only, as if subcontracted: materials, freight, labour, waste. Builder margin, preliminaries and GST are not added, so both assemblies are compared on the same footing.
2. Installed cost of the complete assembly
Central case, per m² of wall (both faces). The full low, central and high inputs are in the CSV in the project repository.
A. Conventional
| Item | Unit | Quantity | Rate | Cost per m² | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A1 90 x 35 MGP10 pine studs at 450 mm, plates and noggins | lm per m2 wall | 3.6 | $3.80 | $13.68 | Our assumption |
| A2 10 mm plasterboard, two faces, with cutting waste | m2 per m2 wall | 2.16 | $6.20 | $13.39 | Our assumption |
| A3 R1.0 wall batts | m2 per m2 wall | 1.05 | $5.00 | $5.25 | Our assumption |
| A4 Screws, nails, tape, compound, corner bead, adhesive | $ per m2 wall | 1 | $4.00 | $4.00 | Our assumption |
| A5 Frame the wall, including door openings | hours per m2 wall | 0.4 | labour rate | $28.00 | Our assumption |
| A6 Fit batts | hours per m2 wall | 0.04 | labour rate | $2.80 | Our assumption |
| A7 Hang plasterboard, two faces | hours per m2 wall | 0.24 | labour rate | $16.80 | Our assumption |
| A8 Tape, set and sand, two faces | hours per m2 wall | 0.3 | labour rate | $21.00 | Our assumption |
| A9 Paint, sealer and two coats, two faces | hours per m2 wall | 0.48 | labour rate | $33.60 | Published productivity, central |
| A10 Paint materials | $ per m2 wall | 1 | $5.40 | $5.40 | Our assumption |
B. Durra Panel
| Item | Unit | Quantity | Rate | Cost per m² | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| B1 Durra Panel S50, natural finish, with cutting waste | m2 per m2 wall | 1.12 | $39.10 | $43.79 | Manufacturer claim |
| B2 Freight, Bendigo to South East Queensland | m2 per m2 wall | 1.12 | $10.00 | $11.20 | Our assumption |
| B3 60 mm galvanised head channel and timber floor plate | lm per m2 wall | 0.74 | $5.00 | $3.70 | Our assumption |
| B4 Biscuit connectors at 500 mm, screws, helical nails | per m2 wall | 1.7 | $1.80 | $3.06 | Our assumption |
| B5 Adhesive, plaster angles, aluminium tape, door channel | $ per m2 wall | 1 | $5.00 | $5.00 | Our assumption |
| B6 Joint compound and skim materials | $ per m2 wall | 1 | $2.50 | $2.50 | Our assumption |
| B7 Set out, cut, stand and fix panels | hours per m2 wall | 0.3 | labour rate | $21.00 | Manufacturer claim (low case) and our assumption |
| B8 Door openings: cut, tape, reinforce jambs and solid-core door channel (4 doors) | hours per m2 wall | 0.0712251 | labour rate | $4.99 | Our assumption |
| B9 Unload, carry, store dry and protect panels (8 to 12 person-hours) | hours per m2 wall | 0.178063 | labour rate | $12.46 | Our assumption |
| B10 Services at outlets and switches: cut recess, route cable, fix box, make good | hours per m2 wall (6 / 8 / 12 points at 0.15 / 0.30 / 0.50 hours) | 0.042735 | labour rate | $2.99 | Our assumption |
| B11 Joint treatment and surface preparation to reach a paintable finish | hours per m2 wall | 0.18 | labour rate | $12.60 | Our assumption |
| B12 Paint with an extra sealer coat on kraft liner, two faces | hours per m2 wall | 0.66 | labour rate | $46.20 | Published productivity (base) plus our assumption |
| B13 Paint materials, extra sealer | $ per m2 wall | 1 | $6.30 | $6.30 | Our assumption |
By cost group, central
| Group | A. Conventional | B. Durra Panel | B minus A |
|---|---|---|---|
| Framing and supporting structure | $13.68 | $3.70 | -$9.98 |
| Panels, plasterboard and insulation | $18.64 | $43.79 | +$25.15 |
| Fixings, junctions, openings and waste | $4.00 | $13.05 | +$9.05 |
| Installation labour | $47.60 | $21.00 | -$26.60 |
| Joint treatment, sanding and painting | $60.00 | $67.60 | +$7.60 |
| Transport and handling | – | $23.66 | +$23.66 |
| Electrical and plumbing service integration | – | $2.99 | +$2.99 |
| Total per m² of wall | $143.92 | $175.79 | +$31.87 |
Low, central and high
| Measure (ex GST) | Low | Central | High |
|---|---|---|---|
| A. Conventional, per m² of wall | $90.53 | $143.92 | $237.70 |
| B. Durra Panel, per m² of wall | $107.86 | $175.79 | $293.25 |
| A. Conventional, 56 m² eligible walls | $5,084 | $8,083 | $13,349 |
| B. Durra Panel, 56 m² eligible walls | $6,058 | $9,873 | $16,469 |
| Difference (B minus A) | +$973 | +$1,790 | +$3,120 |
| Break-even Durra panel price per m², ex GST (reported price $39.10) | $19.45 | $10.64 | $0.61 |
Each assembly’s low case uses its own low inputs, and likewise high. Setting the most favourable Durra inputs against the least favourable conventional inputs, Durra would be -$7,300 (-$129.84 per m²). The reverse pairing gives +$11,400. The sign of the answer therefore depends on the assumptions, which is why a Durra quote and a builder’s rates matter more than anything else.
Cross-checks against published figures
- Our central conventional wall is $144 per m² of wall, or $72 per m² of face. A Brisbane consumer guide gives $60, $95 and $150 per m² of wall face inc GST for a new stud wall sheeted both sides and set ready for paint, or $55, $86 and $136 ex GST (S-D3). Its face basis is unclear, so this is a plausibility check only.
- The manufacturer’s comparison puts conventional at $83.60 per m² and Durra at $77.67, a saving of $5.93 per m². Our conventional cost without set, sand and painting is about $84 per m², close to the manufacturer’s figure, but we do not know what theirs includes. The comparison is a manufacturer claim and is not used in our totals.
Finish scenarios
| Scenario | What changes | Durra per m² of wall (central) | Durra minus conventional | Break-even panel price per m² |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| F1 Natural panels, painted on site | Joint treatment, sealer and two coats (the central case) | $175.79 | +$1,790 | $10.64 |
| F2 Expressed joints, simplified finishing | Joints left visible with trims ($3 per m2 added), no skim or joint set, sealer and two coats still applied | $167.19 | +$1,307 | $18.32 |
| F3 Factory-painted or hardboard-faced panel | Touch-up only: 0.02 hours joints, 0.10 hours paint, $1 paint, freight scaled to 23.3 kg per m2. Hardboard price not published, so read the break-even column | $120.50 | -$1,315 | $60.01 |
| F1 with no extra sealer coat | The manufacturer's sealer replaces the conventional one | $162.29 | +$1,032 | $22.70 |
The manufacturer requires an undercoat sealer straight after installation but names no coating system (S-D2), and says the natural panel is not perfectly flat and shows light surface variation in critical light. The hardboard page offers a smooth face, Dulux colours and panels supplied painted, but gives no price, and does not say whether the painting is done in the factory. F3 is therefore shown as a break-even price, not a cost.
Freight, weight and handling
| Order | Tonnes before packaging | Weight basis |
|---|---|---|
| S50 panels, central order (56.2 m² of wall, 1.12 m² ordered per m²) | 1.16 | 18.5 kg per m² |
| S50, restrictive eligibility (20.0 m²) | 0.41 | |
| S50, permissive eligibility (82.8 m²) | 1.72 | |
| S50 for the earlier wider basis of 102.7 m² (Atlas: about 2.13 tonnes) | 2.13 | Superseded eligibility |
| S58 panels, central area | 1.38 | 22 kg per m² |
| Hardboard panels, central area | 1.47 | 23.3 kg per m² |
Weights are manufacturer data. We hold freight at $5, $10 and $18 per m² of panel as a sensitivity pending a quotation, because the manufacturer says transport is calculated per order from dimensions and quantity. Unloading and handling is tested at 8 to 12 person-hours with a central 10, and mechanical unloading is tested separately (hire cost is our assumption). The panel is an internal product and must be kept dry, so storage and protection matter as much as the tonnage.
Services by outlet and switch
| Location | Item | Count (central) | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Corridor wall, bedroom 3, bedroom 2, robe, bedroom 1 | Light switches | 4 | One per room beside the door |
| Corridor wall | Power outlet | 1 | Cleaning outlet |
| Bedroom 3 | bedroom 2 divider | Power outlets | 2 | Bedhead, one each side |
| Robe | bedroom 1 divider | Power outlet | 1 | Bedroom side |
Outlet and switch counts on eligible walls are our assumption. The Mallee drawings carry no electrical layout. Replace with an electrician's layout. Low 6, central 8, high 12 points. Extra hours per point over a stud wall: 0.15, 0.30 and 0.50. Plumbing: none on the eligible (dry) walls. The manufacturer pages we read say lighting, power outlets and vents can be cut or fixed to the face. They do not confirm factory-installed conduits, so we have not assumed any.
What moves the result
| Change (central case) | A. Conventional | B. Durra Panel | B minus A | Break-even panel price per m² |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base central case | $8,083 | $9,873 | +$1,790 | $10.64 |
| Panel at $30 per m2 (our hypothetical quote) | $8,083 | $9,300 | +$1,218 | $19.74 |
| Panel at $25 per m2 | $8,083 | $8,986 | +$903 | $24.74 |
| No freight (panels collected or delivered free) | $8,083 | $9,244 | +$1,161 | $20.64 |
| Manufacturer labour only (0.21 h per m2) and no door, handling, services or finishing extras | $8,083 | $7,663 | -$420 | $45.77 |
| Durra finishes with no extra prep or sealer (best case for the finish) | $8,083 | $8,407 | +$324 | $33.95 |
| Plasterer rate $90 per hour (labour dearer) | $9,723 | $11,481 | +$1,758 | $11.14 |
| Conventional framing dearer (timber at $5 per lm, batts $7) | $8,443 | $9,873 | +$1,429 | $16.38 |
| Unloading and handling 8 person-hours | $8,083 | $9,733 | +$1,650 | $12.87 |
| Unloading and handling 12 person-hours | $8,083 | $10,013 | +$1,930 | $8.42 |
| Mechanical unloading: hire $450 (our assumption), 3 person-hours | $8,083 | $9,833 | +$1,750 | $11.28 |
| Freight $5 per m2 (low) | $8,083 | $9,558 | +$1,475 | $15.64 |
| Freight $18 per m2 (high) | $8,083 | $10,376 | +$2,293 | $2.64 |
| Services: 12 points at 0.5 hours | $8,083 | $10,125 | +$2,042 | $6.64 |
| Services: generic chasing allowance of 0.10 hours per m2 instead of by point | $8,083 | $10,098 | +$2,015 | $7.06 |
Whole-wall sensitivity to how much wall is eligible:
| Eligible wall area | A. Conventional | B. Durra Panel | B minus A |
|---|---|---|---|
| Restrictive: only the two bedroom dividers (20.0 m²) | $2,876 | $3,512 | +$637 |
| Central: plus the dry corridor wall (56.2 m²) | $8,083 | $9,873 | +$1,790 |
| Permissive: plus study and kitchen walls (82.8 m²) | $11,914 | $14,553 | +$2,638 |
3. Labour
| Measure | Low | Central | High |
|---|---|---|---|
| Labour hours, conventional (eligible walls) | 61 | 82 | 112 |
| Labour hours, Durra Panel | 53 | 80 | 113 |
| Hours saved by Durra (our model) | 8 | 2 | -1 |
| Labour value of those hours at the case rate | $451 | $110 | -$116 |
| Hours saved if the manufacturer's 16 against 6 hours are person-hours, scaled to this area | 20 | ||
| Hours saved if the 16 hours is elapsed time for two trades (32 person-hours) against 6 | 51 |
Manufacturer comparison for one 12 m x 2.4 m wall, reported in our Durra Panel profile. What it includes, the GST basis, crew sizes and the finish are unconfirmed. Person-hours or elapsed hours is not confirmed. The manufacturer pages we read give no installation hours and do not show the comparison. If the 16 hours is elapsed time for two trades, the conventional wall took 32 person-hours, and the scaled saving is much larger than if both are person-hours, so the two readings are shown above. Their six hours against 16 covers fixing the panels and building the stud wall with its linings. It does not appear to cover joint setting, painting, services or door openings, all of which we include. The labour hours in our model are our assumptions, apart from the paint productivity (S-D5).
4. Programme and critical path
We re-run the baseline critical path with the partition changes only. Each case uses the same case of the baseline durations and the same case of the hours above. Crew sizes are the baseline crews.
| Measure | Low | Central | High |
|---|---|---|---|
| Conventional baseline, working days incl. weather | 57 | 94 | 163 |
| With Durra partitions, working days | 57.0 | 96.5 | 168.4 |
| Change, working days | +0.0 | +2.5 | +5.4 |
| Change, weeks | +0.0 | +0.5 | +1.1 |
| Task changed (central case) | Baseline days | Durra days | On critical path |
|---|---|---|---|
| T6 Wall frames, roof trusses and bracing | 12 | 11.3 | Yes |
| D1 Durra Panel partitions: set out, stand, fix, reinforce door openings (after roof on, windows in progress) | new | 1.3 | Yes |
| T9a Rough-in: roof, ceiling and external wall services (unchanged) | new | 4.8 | |
| T9b Rough-in: partition services, chased into panels | new | 3.3 | Yes |
| T10 Wall and ceiling insulation | 3 | 2.9 | Yes |
| T11 Plasterboard hanging and setting | 10 | 9.4 | Yes |
| T16 Painting, two coats | 10 | 10.4 | Yes |
Durra's residential guidance says the building envelope must be weathertight before installation, and the panel is an internal product that must be kept dry (S-D2). Panels therefore start only after the roof, windows, doors and cladding are all complete (T7 and T8 finished), not while windows are still being fitted. Partition rough-in waits for the panels, the rest of the rough-in does not. The central change is small and sits well inside the uncertainty of the baseline itself, which we label an indicative efficient programme and not a verified industry average. A panel wall does remove framing and plasterboard hanging from the partitions, but it adds a new task, delays partition rough-in until the panels are up, and lengthens painting. Panel lead time from Bendigo is not in this programme.
5. Performance, risks and life cycle
| Item | Conventional | Durra Panel | Our reading | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Thermal | 10 mm board and R1.0 batts in a 90 mm cavity, as specified for the 8.5 star option | S50 thermal resistance 0.62 m2K/W, conductivity 0.081 W/mK (manual 6.2.5, one source) | Internal partitions do not form part of the NatHERS envelope, so thermal value is not a cost driver here. Thermal mass effects have not been modelled. | Manufacturer claim |
| Acoustic | No figure sourced by us. Plasterboard manufacturers publish tested systems. To read. | Manual tests: S50 panel alone STC 31, S58 alone STC 34, single S50 with 10 mm plasterboard both sides STC 31 (ST-14), double S58 disconnected Rw 57. Tests are older, from several labs, and mostly report STC, not Rw. | Acoustic equivalence is not demonstrated. A single Durra panel has not been shown to match the insulated conventional partition. We understand the NCC sets no sound insulation requirement for internal walls inside a detached house, but a certifier should confirm, and privacy between bedrooms is a quality question. | Manufacturer claim |
| Fire | Plasterboard systems carry tested fire ratings | The manual states a one hour rating for a fire-rated panel joint (6.1.2) with no test standard or report cited. We found no fire test report. | Do not use Durra for a garage separation or any wall that needs a fire rating until a current test report is obtained. | Manufacturer claim |
| Wet areas | Waterproofed wet area lining and tile | Paper-faced straw panel is moisture sensitive. The manual offers a 4.5 mm cement sheet laminate option but we found no wet area details. | We keep every wall with a tiled or wet face conventional in both cases (40.9 m2 of face, an upper bound for partitions). | Our assumption |
| Fixings and loads | Fix anywhere to studs, noggins for heavy loads | Light fittings use wood screws, heavy fittings may need special devices (6.3.6). Kitchen and bathroom fixings need noggin equivalents. | Possible extra cost for joinery fixings, not priced. | Manufacturer claim |
| Transport and handling | Local supply, packs of boards and timber, same-day delivery | Made to order in Bendigo. Weight 18.5 kg per m2 (S50), 22 (S58), 23.3 (hardboard). Panels 1,187 mm wide, up to 3,600 mm long. Internal product, must be kept dry. Transport is calculated per order from dimensions and quantity. | About 1.2 tonnes of S50 for the central eligible walls, before packaging. Unloading, storage and protection from rain are real costs and risks. Lead time and packaging are not stated by the manufacturer. | Our assumption |
| Maintenance and repair | Patch and repaint. Damage is cheap to repair. Services can be reached by cutting a board. | Impact damage to a 50 mm panel is a repair of the panel face. Re-running services means chasing the panel. | No data on repair costs or durability in service. | Our assumption |
| End of life | Plasterboard can be recycled where facilities exist, timber reused or chipped, batts usually landfilled | An EPD (S-P-10940) exists and is verified in our product profile. We have not extracted its end-of-life scenario for this comparison. | A possible circularity advantage, but not demonstrated here. | Open |
| Floor area | 110 mm wall (90 mm studs and two 10 mm boards) | 50 mm panel (S50) with paint, 53.2 mm for the hardboard panel | Thinner partitions may add usable floor area. See the note below the table. | Our calculation |
Thinner partitions could add usable floor area. At 60 mm saved per wall (110 mm conventional against 50 mm S50), the eligible length of 20.8 m adds about 1.2 m2 of usable floor in the central case (0.4 to 1.8 m2). Atlas's earlier figure of about 2.3 m2 corresponds to about 38 m of partition, our earlier wider eligibility, and all 53.2 m would give 3.2 m2. These are subject to detailing and performance requirements and are not in the cost comparison.
6. Ceilings, investigated separately
The Mallee conventional ceiling is 10 mm plasterboard on timber framing with R4.0 batts (Mallee 8.5 star option), 148 m2, of which 48.6 m2 is raked.
- The Durra ceiling system is a roof and ceiling system built on a steel grid: Duplex or I-beam runners at 1,200 mm centres, Tee units, galvanised wedges at about 450 mm to clamp each panel down, perimeter support of 25 mm, suspension rods where the grid hangs, and a 60 kg per pair limit on the services bracket (manual sections 3, 4 and 9). It is not a panel screwed to timber joists.
- The Mallee ceiling is plasterboard on timber, with R4.0 batts above. The panel's own thermal resistance is R0.62 for S50, so batts or another insulation layer are still needed for the 8.5 star envelope. A Durra ceiling therefore replaces the board and perhaps the timber, but not the insulation, and adds a steel grid.
- We have not found span, load, bracing or diaphragm data for the panel itself, and the manual's installation sequence is written for large commercial and industrial roofs (a module of about 100 m2 placed by 5 to 6 people in an hour, which the manual says not to use for estimating).
- Services in a ceiling void, such as light fittings, ducted or split air conditioning and the roof space, need access. A closed panel ceiling does not give it without extra detailing.
- Possible niche: the 48.6 m2 of raked ceiling, where a panel could serve as a self-supporting, finished surface between rafters. That depends on span data we do not have.
Conclusion. We have not costed a Durra ceiling. On the evidence we hold, we cannot show that the wall system transfers, and the steel grid probably works against it for a house. The questions for Ortech are listed below.
Questions for the manufacturer:
- Maximum span and load for S50 and S58 between timber or steel rafters at 600, 900 and 1,200 mm centres.
- Whether a timber-framed residential ceiling detail exists, and its tested fire, acoustic and bracing behaviour.
- Thermal resistance of the panel in a ceiling with a ventilated roof space, and whether it can sit under R4.0 batts without condensation risk in a humid climate.
- Access for services and for roof space, and how the panel is cut for downlights and ducting.
- Delivered price, lead time and panel weight to Brisbane for a house-sized order.
7. Sources and how we read them
The sources below were read by us through page summaries from a fetch tool, not the original documents, unless the table says otherwise. Anything not named here that we reuse is reported by research partner, not read by us.
| ID | Source | Date | Class | How read | What we used it for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| S-D1 | Ortech Durra Panel technical manual, Rev 4 (MKT100) | 2022 (rev 4) | Manufacturer claim | Page summaries from the fetch tool for sections 1 to 9 (about two thirds of the document). Not the original PDF. Section 7 test tables appear as a summary. | Wall and ceiling system details, acoustic test index, thermal values, fire statement |
| S-D2 | Durra Panel product pages (natural, hardboard) and FAQ, durrapanel.com | Read 16 November 2026 | Manufacturer claim | Page summaries from the fetch tool, not the original pages. Pages: /product/natural/, /product/hardboard/, /faqs/. The FAQ says "transport costs are calculated per order" and gives 18.5 kg per m2. It does not state installation hours or the 12 m x 2.4 m comparison. | Weights, hardboard panel (23.3 kg per m2, 53.2 mm, lengths 2,400, 2,700 and 3,600 mm, supplied painted), weathertight requirement, undercoat sealer requirement, one hour fire statement, cement sheet finish for wet areas, price from $39.10 per m2 (earlier profile) |
| S-D3 | What's the Damage, Brisbane plastering cost guide | Verified November 2026 | Published benchmark (secondary, consumer cost guide) | Page summary from the fetch tool. The page's whole-house figure conflicts with its per m2 rate, so we use it only as a rough check. | Plasterer rate $50 / $77 / $120 per hour inc GST. New non-loadbearing stud wall sheeted both sides and set ready for paint $60 / $95 / $150 per m2 of wall face inc GST (face basis unclear) |
| S-D4 | SureQuote plastering cost guide | October 2026 | Published benchmark (secondary) | Page summary from the fetch tool | Plastering labour rate $70 per hour ex GST |
| S-D5 | Resene paint productivity tables | Read 2026 | Published benchmark (paint manufacturer) | Page summary from the fetch tool | 0.24 hours per m2 for walls on new plasterboard (sealer and two coats), 0.09 hours per m2 for an extra sealer coat |
| S-D6 | Mallee House (Brisbane) Design Options, pages 6 to 7, and technical drawings | Government design, read by us in the original PDF | Verified (drawing data) | Original PDF read by us | Partition and ceiling make-up, ceiling height, door and window schedule |
8. Uncertainties and quotations needed
| Item | What to ask | What it affects | Who |
|---|---|---|---|
| Durra delivered price | Written quote for S50 and S58, delivered to Brisbane, GST basis, lead time, minimum order. | Break-even price. This is the single most important input. | Supplier |
| Freight and handling | Freight cost, panel weight, pallet size, storage and protection advice. | Transport line, programme | Supplier |
| Finish | What finish does the manufacturer recommend for a Level 4 painted wall, and what does it cost to install? | Joint treatment and painting lines | Supplier and a painter |
| Services | Approved methods for cabling, switches, powerpoints and plumbing in a panel wall. | Services integration, rough-in programme | Supplier and electrician |
| Fire and acoustic | Current test reports for a residential partition, including Rw and Rw+Ctr, and any fire test for the joint. | Whether Durra can serve walls near the garage or between bedrooms | Supplier and certifier |
| Wet areas | Whether a cement-sheet faced panel is suitable behind tile, with membrane details. | Eligible wall area | Supplier and certifier |
| Conventional rates | A builder's or plasterer's installed rate per m2 for the partition assembly, with labour hours. | Conventional side of every comparison | Builder or quantity surveyor |
| Eligible wall area | Wall by wall list of wet, garage and structural partitions on the Mallee plans. | Quantity of Durra partition | Us, from the drawings |
| Ceilings | Span, load, thermal and service data for S50 and S58 in a timber-framed ceiling. | Whether a ceiling scenario is worth costing | Supplier |
| Installation hours basis | Are the manufacturer's 16 and 6 hours person-hours or elapsed crew hours, for how many people, and what do they include? We could not find the comparison on the manufacturer FAQ page we read. | Labour saving could be 36 or 93 hours | Supplier |
| Coating system | Which sealer, undercoat and topcoat system does the manufacturer recommend for natural panels, how many coats, and does the sealer replace the usual one? | Extra sealer coat in the central case | Supplier and a painter |
| Conduit and services | Are factory-installed conduits or channels available, and what is the approved method for outlets and switches? | Services lines | Supplier and electrician |
| Hardboard and factory-painted panels | Price per m2, whether the paint is applied in the factory, colour range, joint detail and lead time. | Finish scenario F3 break-even | Supplier |
| Wall by wall eligibility | Which partitions are load-bearing, braced or fire-rated, and which carry joinery or services? | Eligible area (20, 56 or 83 m2) | Designer and engineer |
| Mechanical unloading | Truck-mounted crane or forklift hire and delivery access for a 1.2 tonne order. | Handling line | Supplier and carrier |
Back to The Circular Home, the cost and programme baseline, the assembly comparisons or the Durra Panel profile.