The Circular Home · Research update

Foundation comparison.

Four ways to support the reference building, compared on the same hypothetical site.

Status: a research framework. Nothing below is a quotation or an engineering design. Each cell is a direction to test, not a finding, until we have an engineer and supplier information for the same site.

The 100 mm slab in the Mallee specification

Our research partner reports that the NCC 2022 ABCB Housing Provisions illustrate 100 mm slab panels within certain footing and stiffened raft systems: Part 4.2 (footings and slabs), clause 4.2.14 (stiffened rafts, Class A, S and M sites), Figures 4.2.14a and 4.2.14b, NCC Volume Two H1D4 and AS 2870. There is reported to be no universal 125 mm minimum for every residential footing system. We have not read the provisions ourselves, so this is reported, not checked. Source: NCC 2022 ABCB Housing Provisions (PDF).

The Mallee document appears to specify the slab panel for energy modelling. The 100 mm figure is therefore not inherently non-compliant, and it does not establish the footing design. Edge beams, internal beams, reinforcement, site classification and footing design are unknown. Queensland is reported to apply NCC 2022 until it adopts NCC 2025 on 1 May 2027 (Business Queensland, building laws, codes and standards).

These theoretical slab panel volumes use the stated 174 m² footprint. They are sensitivity calculations, not foundation quantities. They exclude beams, footings, rebates, set-downs and waste.

Slab panel thicknessTheoretical volume over 174 m²Difference from 100 mm
100 mm17.40 m³
125 mm21.75 m³+4.35 m³ (25%)
150 mm26.10 m³+8.70 m³ (50%)

A hypothetical Class S site

Hypothetical scenario For a first comparison we assume a Class S site (slightly reactive clay, as we understand AS 2870), flat, with ordinary access. We have not confirmed that Class S is suitable for this research or how common it is in South East Queensland, and the choice may change. We will then test Class M, and later Class H, where ground movement is larger and the answer for each system may change. We do not assume one foundation system suits every site. Screw piles in particular depend on ground conditions and slope.

What we will compare

Four systems, fourteen criteria. Entries describe what each system involves in general, with company claims marked as such.

CriterionStiffened raft (conventional)EPS waffle podBIAXScrew piles with suspended floor
ExcavationTrimmed ribs and edge beams in a shallow excavationShallow excavation with a level padAs for a waffle slabMinimal bulk excavation, with pile positions only. Site access for a drill rig is a question
Imported fillOften needed to form a level pad. Quantity depends on the siteAs for a raftAs for a raftMay need little, because the floor is suspended. Depends on slope and drainage
Concrete volumeSlab panel plus ribs and edge beams (17.4 m³ is the panel alone at 100 mm)Often claimed to use less concrete than a conventional raft. To verifyCompany claims less concrete. To verify (see profile)No ground slab. Pile caps or foundations if any. Concrete may still be used elsewhere
ReinforcementMesh and bar in ribs, set by the engineerSet by the engineerCompany claims lower-grade reinforcement. To verifySteel piles and framing carry loads. Floor framing is timber or steel
Void formersNoneExpanded polystyrene podsRecycled polypropylene void formersNone
FormworkEdge formwork and trench forming for ribsEdge formwork. Pods form the ribsEdge formwork. Void formers form the ribsNone for slab. Pile positioning and bracing
LabourUnknown, to quoteUnknown, to quoteCompany claims faster installation. UnverifiedSpecialist pile installer plus floor framing crew. Unknown, to quote
EquipmentExcavator, concrete pump, finishersAs for a raft, plus pod handlingAs for a waffle slab, plus void former handlingScrew pile drive head and rig, crane or lifting for framing
Construction durationUnknown, to quoteUnknown, to quoteCompany claims faster. UnverifiedUnknown, to quote
Thermal performanceMallee specifies no under-slab insulation. Slab-on-ground thermal mass helps the modelled resultVoids can change edge and underfloor behaviour. Needs modellingNeeds modelling. Void material and air gap differ from EPSInsulated suspended floor is possible but loses slab thermal mass. Needs modelling
Embodied emissionsDriven mostly by concrete and steel quantitiesLess concrete may be offset by fossil-based EPS. To assessRecycled polypropylene. The product EPD is summarised in our profileSteel piles and framing. Needs a life cycle comparison
WasteConcrete overpour and formwork offcutsEPS offcuts and podsReusable pods. Reported, unverifiedFew site wastes. Framing offcuts
Engineering requirementsFooting design to AS 2870 for the site classFooting design to AS 2870 for the site classEngineer-designed. Manufacturer reports certification (see profile)Engineer-designed for loads and soil. Ground conditions affect feasibility
Total installed costUnknown, to quoteUnknown, to quoteUnknown, to quote. No whole-slab cost has been publishedUnknown, to quote

See the BIAX profile for what we have verified about that system.

What we need next

  1. A structural engineer’s indicative designs for all four systems on the same hypothetical Class S site.
  2. Supplier quotes using the quotation schedule: concrete, reinforcement, pods, piles, labour, equipment and programme.
  3. Thermal modelling of each floor type in the Mallee design (NatHERS), since the design relies on slab thermal mass.
  4. A life cycle comparison for the same slab area and the same service life.

Back to The Circular Home, the reference building and takeoff or the quotation schedule.